I have to admit, I started out fairly
non-committal. But anthems can be sung
at all sorts of tempos and in all sorts of styles; I reserve judgment. Both anthems, at first, seemed okay but not
terribly inspiring. Both now are growing
on me.
As I’ve said, national anthems are meant for the
people of the nations in question; an outsider will never react the same way as
a native.
I was intrigued by some of the comments I noticed on
YouTube. One person called one of the
anthems a dirge. This was understandably
met with some indignation from a loyal citizen.
I began with the intention of avoiding the confusing
of these two countries. People here, in
the U.S., forever connect them, I think; and they do both share British
heritage; yet they are quite different, both in history and geography—and I
always stress this to my friends here.
Yet the more I listen to the two anthems, the more I seem to confuse
them. I’m going to have to work on
this! Perhaps—again—because the
recordings I’m listening to are sung in a similar, rather “pop” style. But also, perhaps, because I sense they both
have something, again, of the Anglican-style hymn in them.
The sense of the Australian anthem is that Australia
is blessed with many riches, let’s do good things with them. I’ve always felt this was a good approach for
a national anthem.
The New Zealand anthem has verses in English, but
also in Maori. The Maori, apparently, is
now sung first. This reflects, in
multiple ways, differences between New Zealand and Australia. At first I found the English lyrics a bit
expansive—asking God to defend the country; speaking in the following verses of
the desire for peace but expressing the willingness to fight for the land if it
is threatened. By comparison, the Maori
lyrics seemed simple and straight-forward:
Bless us, God; may Good flourish.
Defend the Land.
But I only have the translation for the first Maori
verse, so I’m at a disadvantage here.
I’ll be listening to both of the anthems more. They are little-known in the U.S. Check them out on YouTube.
What intrigues me most, at this point, is how I am
mixing the two melodies up, in spite of my determination not to. Is it me, or the music?
No comments:
Post a Comment